Jewelry Store Review, Best Pieces

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, Rolling Stone may receive an affiliate commission.

Jewelry is the ultimate gift. Good pieces can last for generations, and giftees will always be reminded of the occasion — and the loved one — who gave them that special piece of jewelry. At the zenith of jewelry gifting are diamond pieces (perhaps alongside fine watches). The symbolism of a nearly-indestructible stone and, of course, the sparkly wow-factor are impossible to argue, and make a great choice for all gifting occasions (not just engagements).

If you’re in the market for a jewelry gift, one place we recommend looking is Blue Nile. Founded in 1999, the brand is the original online jewelry retailer and still one of the most trusted sources for diamond jewelry. The retailer sources conflict-free diamonds and offers education services for choosing the right pieces. They’ve since expanded to other types of jewelry, but diamonds remain their bread and butter. Plus, Blue Nile has impeccable customer service, ensuring that the ordering and any follow-up processes are painless.

For a great impression of what Blue Nile is all about, check out their new Bezel collection here.

We’re not alone in our appreciation for Blue Nile. Helen Mirren, Brooklyn Decker, Grimm star Bitsie Tulloch, and Giuliana Rancic are just a few celebrities who have been spotted wearing Blue Nile jewelry on red carpets.

Gift Ideas From Blue Nile

Looking to pick up a high-quality jewelry gift? Be sure to stop by Blue Nile. Check out their curated gift guide here (categorized by price), or see some of our favorites down below.

One of our favorite pieces from Blue Nile’s new Bezel collection — and a great pice to gift — is this emerald cut diamond ring, set in 18K yellow gold.

You can’t go wrong with a classic pair of gold hoops. This petite style measures two by 15 millimeters of 14k yellow gold tubing and comes in at a sale price of just $144.

If you’re looking for a great diamond necklace under $1,000, this is the one to get. It features a floating lab-grown diamond dangling from a high-quality 14K white gold chain (also available in yellow gold). It’s discreet and easy to pair with both casual and dressed-up outfits.

Another one of the best gifts from Blue Nile for less than $1,000 is this Starlight ring. Ten diamonds are fixed in a 14K gold (yellow or white). The band measures 4.15 millimeters wide.

Looking to gift some elegant, eye-catching earrings? Check out these oval tanzanite and diamond studs. Diamond halos surround the central stone, and they’re all held together with 14K white gold. Also available with a green emerald in the center.

Bracelet sizing is always tough, but we think Blue Nile nailed it with this wheat chain in 14K Italian yellow gold. It’s thick enough to make an impression but slim enough to pair with a huge range of outfits and other jewelry.

For a diamond ring that’s under $2,000, pick up this three-row piece. 33 diamonds of various sizes are set in rows on 14K white gold, producing a unique, dazzling sparkle from every angle.